
Reddit Reaction · For Sellers
Dual Agency in Georgia: Is Your Agent Really Yours?
August 17, 2026 · 3 min 43 sec · Megan Cox
A seller got multiple full price offers on day one. One was cash from a neighbor with no agent, so her agent ended up on both sides of the deal. Nobody ever told her she could go back and ask for highest and best.
What she posted
We sold our house a year ago. Three agents gave us an estimate that felt fifteen to twenty thousand under what the comps supported, and inventory was low. We were in the top rated school district, but we agreed and listed at $179,000.
First day we had an open house and got multiple full price offers, which told me the price was too low from the start. One offer was full cash from a neighbor with no agent, so our agent ended up representing both sides. My agent never told me I could counter or open it back up for other buyers to bid higher.
Looking back, I think my agent steered me toward a lower estimate to make it a faster, easier sale, and did not push for a bidding war because the cash offer meant a full commission with no split.
Read the full transcript
We’re going to start doing Reddit reactions. So I go on Reddit, I read a story from someone, summarize it up, and then I’m going to give my reaction as a real estate agent.
So this person summarized says that they sold their house a year ago, and they got three agents to give an estimate that they felt was $15 to $20,000 under what they felt the comps were, and that there was low inventory. So they were suggesting that it was worth more. But even though they were in the top-rated school district, they agreed and listed it at $179,000.
First day, they had an open house, and they got multiple full-price offers, which to them told them that the price was too low from the start. One offer was full cash from a neighbor with no agent, so the agent ended up representing both sides. My agent never told me that I could counter offer or open it up for other buyers to rebid higher. Looking back, I think my agent may have steered me, which, you know, in real estate that word is like, so not a great choice wording there. But anyways, I think my agent just steered me toward a lower estimate to make it a faster, easier sell, and did not push for a bidding war because the cash meant a full commission with no split.
When I bought my next home, I used the seller’s agent instead of getting my own, thinking it would put me in a better position, not realizing that it meant that nobody was actually working for me, either. They’re basically complaining about how that situation went.
So there’s multiple parts of that story. One, you are always welcome to run comps on your own house. I love it. Like, usually when I go into a listing appointment, I’ll have my comps, but I’m like, “Let’s see, where are you at? Like, what is your thoughts on this house? Like, on the pricing.” So I think that’s fine. A lot of times, unfortunately, our hearts value the house more than what the actual dollar sign it’s worth. So sometimes that does happen. So the price range I don’t think is that big of a deal.
Multiple offers on day one and open house, she said that meant her house was priced too low. Could have been. Could have been. Who knows? But not necessarily. Just because you get multiple offers on a house does not mean that it’s priced too low. It’s just a desirable house. Now, sometimes, yes, I have seen houses where I see it posted and it’s like probably 30,000 below what it’s actually worth and the agent’s like, “Under contract, 24 hours, multiple offers.” Well, duh. So that can happen. But that is not always the case if you get multiple offers that it’s too low.
The part with that that I felt was a red flag was that the agent didn’t give any insight on, yes, you can go to these people and say, “Hey, we’ve received multiple offers. Please come in with your highest and best.” That was a miss, in my opinion, as an agent, that I would have definitely done.
I don’t know that they were steering or anything like that. I would never accuse any agent of that. But being able to represent both sides, that’s a tricky situation. In Georgia, it is technically legal where you can do dual agency. At our brokerage, it’s not. So I do not do dual agency. I have done where I have done a for sale by owner and I actually have the buyer and I bring it. So I do the contract for both sides, but all I am is working as a transaction broker for the seller. That is not dual agency. So I’ve done that. But I can see where they would feel that the agent wanted the commission on both sides.
I hope that wasn’t the case, but in my world, if I was to list this house and we were to get multiple offers, no matter if the cash came in, no matter if they were unrepresented, any of that, we would definitely go over all offers. I’m going to provide to you like basically a spreadsheet to show you the bigger picture. So we’ve got offer 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. This one’s this, this one’s this, this one’s this. This is where offer one’s going to net you, this is where offer two’s going to net you, and just give you a bigger picture. And we would always go back and say, “Hey, we’ve received multiple offers. What’s your highest and best?” So that’s what I would do. For this week’s Reddit reaction, see you next week.
Run your own comps, I love it
You are always welcome to pull comparable sales on your own house. When I go into a listing appointment I have my comps ready, but the first thing I ask is where are you at, what do you think this house is worth.
Here is the honest part though. A lot of the time our hearts value the house higher than the market does. That is human and it happens constantly. So the price range in her story does not strike me as the real problem.
Multiple offers does not automatically mean underpriced
She read a stack of day one offers as proof she left money on the table. Maybe. It could have been. But not necessarily. Sometimes it just means the house was desirable and there was nothing else like it available.
Now, have I seen houses posted thirty thousand under what they are worth, and the agent announces under contract in twenty four hours with multiple offers? Yes. Well, duh. That happens. But it is not the automatic explanation every time.
This was the actual miss
The red flag for me was not the price. It was that nobody told her she could go back to those buyers and say we have received multiple offers, please come back with your highest and best.
That is a standard move. That is the whole point of having competition on your house. Leaving it on the table was a miss, and it is one I would have caught.
What dual agency actually means in Georgia
Dual agency is when one agent, or one brokerage, represents both the buyer and the seller in the same deal. Georgia allows it, but only with written consent from both sides. You have to agree to it in writing, and you should never sign something you do not understand.
My brokerage does not permit it, so I do not do dual agency. I have done a for sale by owner where I brought the buyer and wrote the contract for both sides, but there I am working as a transaction broker for the seller. That is a different thing.
I am not going to accuse anybody of steering. I do not know what that agent was thinking. But I can absolutely see why she felt the commission on both sides mattered more than her number did.
How I handle multiple offers
If I list your house and offers come in, it does not matter whether one is cash or the buyer is unrepresented. We go over all of them together.
I build you a spreadsheet so you can see the whole picture. Offer one, two, three, four, five. What each one is, and what each one actually nets you at the end. Because the biggest number is not always the best number once you account for terms.
And then we go back to all of them and ask for highest and best. Every time.
Where dual agency gets uncomfortable
It is not automatically a bad thing, and plenty of deals close that way without a single issue. These are the three moments it starts to matter.
01
The price conversation
A dual agent cannot tell the buyer the lowest you would take, and cannot tell you the most the buyer would pay. They become a referee instead of an advocate.
02
Repairs after the inspection
Somebody needs to be firmly in your corner saying what they really think about that repair request. Neutral is not the same as on your side.
03
Appraisal gaps and credits
These are the moments real money moves. If your agent goes quiet on advice exactly when the money conversation starts, that is worth asking about directly.
Ask these before you sign anything
Good answers to these four tell you almost everything. If you are getting ready to list, my sellers page walks through how I handle pricing and negotiation, and if you are on the buying side, start here instead.
If this one hit home
You deserve somebody whose only job is you
That is how I have run my business for over seven years across Henry, Butts, Pike, Lamar, and the surrounding counties. If you are unsure about your representation right now, let’s talk it through.
Tell me what story you want me to react to next, and subscribe over on my YouTube channel. You can also reach me at 678-990-6133.
Megan Cox, REALTOR®, Move with Megan at The Legacy Real Estate Group, Georgia. This is general information and not legal advice. Please consult your broker or attorney for your specific situation. Equal Housing Opportunity.
