The Legacy Real Estate GroupBrokerage Office: 470-781-1244
Office:45 John Frank Ward Blvd
McDonough, GA 30253
Hours:Mon – Sat
7am – 7pm
Megan Cox:678-990-6133
Market Updates & Real Estate Tips

Can Your Realtor Buy Your House? What to Know

Megan Cox video on whether your realtor can buy your house in Georgia
← All videos

Reddit Reaction · For Sellers

Can Your Realtor Buy Your House? What to Know

September 15, 2026 · 5 min 12 sec · Megan Cox

Forty one days on the market. Twenty eight showings. Zero offers. Then their agent texts and says he is thinking about buying the house himself for cash. Her gut said run. Here is what I actually think.

What she posted

We chose our agent because our handyman recommended him. They both told us our home would sell within four hours. It has been 41 days. We have had 28 showings and zero offers.

We also have solar panels we owe 18,000 on. He told us the market was so hot he could find someone to take over those payments. For the past three weeks we have been advertising that we will pay them off ourselves.

Today he texted and said he is actually thinking of buying the house from us for cash if we can work on a good price. My BS radar has been going off since day one, but my husband really likes him. Is this normal? Have we screwed up?

Read the full transcript

Okay, we’re back for another Reddit review. This one is about our real estate agent wants to buy our house. Is that normal?

So, it says, “We chose our real estate agent because our handyman recommended him. They both told us that our home would sell within 4 hours. It’s in Charleston, South Carolina. It’s been 41 days. We’ve had 28 showings and zero offers. We apparently missed the hot seller market. We bought the home in 2017 for $239,000. He listed the home for $344,900 in June. We also have solar panels that we owe 18,000 on. He told us that in this market it was so hot he could find someone to take over those payments. For the past three weeks, we have been advertising that we will pay off the solar panels. Today, he texted us and said, ‘I’m actually also thinking of buying the house from you guys also for cash if we can work on a good price.’ My BS radar has been going off since day one, but my husband, he really likes them. Is this normal? Have we screwed up? Do real estate agents typically offer to buy their seller’s house? Is this a good option or should we run for the hills? I’m sick to my stomach. We are emotionally and physically exhausted from cleaning and cleaning and never receiving much feedback.”

“I’m incredibly grateful for all the feedback, advice, and suggestions from the professionals and amateurs alike. It really gave us a lot to think about and many of you made some amazing points and helped better equip us with some knowledge going forward. We decided to take a mix of feedback and compromise with my husband. He spoke to the realtor who asked him to give him 12 days to sell the house at a lower price or he would make an offer. He has until Wednesday to make us an offer himself or get an offer for the home for 310,000. We said that if it doesn’t happen then we ask to be released from the contract.”

And then they updated again and said he did it. He had one showing today to get an offer at our minimum asking price, which is 315. He did it. Got an offer by Wednesday. If he didn’t get an offer by Wednesday or make the offer himself, we were going to terminate the contract. With a little motivation and a market that was ready, a little luck, and some prayers, we got our first offer for 315,000. We’re accepting it and hope everything goes smoothly. Thank you, Reddit community.

Okay, so that was on August 3rd. So, I guess he got an offer and he didn’t buy it himself. But anyways, so if all that was to be said, my thing is the agent made some promises that me being an agent, I would never do. It doesn’t matter how hot the house is. If it has all the bells and whistles, like a house in Georgia here, like it would be a really hot desirable house would be like a ranch on a finished basement with an inground pool and like you throw in a detached garage and you’re like, “Wow, people love it.” But even then, I don’t want to tell someone like, “Oh, I’m going to have it sold in 4 days.” You just never know. Like, yes, it’s a desirable house, but I don’t want to make promises that I can’t keep because I don’t want them coming back at me.

Another thing is, now keep in mind, this is a different market. This is in Charleston, South Carolina. So maybe solar panels are very popular there. They’re around here, but they’re not very popular. If you decide to do things like that, like upgrade your house, like if you put in a pool and you finance it, that’s a common thing. You can now finance your HVAC, you can finance, I believe companies are even letting you finance if you do a new roof, solar panels, anything like that.

This is my opinion, but you chose to do those upgrades and chose to do those things that I feel should fall on you. So, them saying, “We now offered to pay off the solar panels.” That to me isn’t an incentive because you should have. You chose to put the solar panels up, you should finish paying them off. That’s just my opinion. Like, if you upgrade the HVAC and you finance it, at closing you should be paying that off. That’s my opinion. If you found a buyer that was like, “I love your house so much and I’ll take over the payments,” that would be considered lucky to me. That wouldn’t be considered normal.

And then the agent offering to buy. Now, depending on what they’re willing to offer, I do not think that’s uncommon. I have bought one time, but I went to them very straightforward and said, “Hey, you came to me wanting to sell this house. This is what I see, this is the things that it needs.” It was a flip home and it needs all these things and I would like to buy it at this price. “If you do not want to sell it to me at that price, I completely understand. If you think that’s too low of a price or anything like that, you want me to put it on the market, you want me to find investors, all of that, I will do.” So, I was very transparent, but I said what I wanted to do, what I wanted to put into it, and that worked out for us. So I don’t think that’s a weird thing to do.

Now, let’s say that the house doesn’t need anything and they come to you with like some crazy lowball offer. Yeah, that would be crazy. But if it’s a house like this house, it doesn’t seem like it needed a lot of work. I think that maybe he was going to try to purchase it and make it a rental would be what I would think. And some agents do that. I don’t, but some do. So, I don’t think that that’s the craziest thing.

Just if you feel weird about that, if you have a house on the market and your agent offers you a price, why don’t you just maybe ask for them to pay for, or you pay for, a private appraisal and see what your home’s worth to go back and forth on that? Like not just what the agent says it’s worth, pay for a true appraisal and then maybe decide if that’s something you want to do.

But that is not very uncommon, actually very common, like that the agents are going to buy the house. But if it’s a flip, they may have investors that want to buy the house and they’ll bring the investor to you, which is something I’ve done. Like if you call me and you have a house that needs a lot of work, we do have investors we work with and we send them out. So that’s very common. But that’s this week’s review.

The four hour promise was the first mistake

This is the part that actually bothers me, and it happened before anybody mentioned buying anything. Her agent told her the house would sell within four hours.

I would never say that. It does not matter how hot a house is or how many bells and whistles it has. Around here the most desirable thing on the market is a ranch on a finished basement with an inground pool, and throw in a detached garage and people lose their minds over it. Even then I am not telling you it sells in four days.

You just never know. I am not going to make a promise I cannot keep, because I do not want you coming back at me when it does not happen. And in this case it did not happen, and now she does not trust a word he says.

Financed upgrades are your bill, not a bonus

They owe eighteen thousand on solar panels, and their agent told them he could find a buyer to take over the payments. For three weeks they have been advertising that they will pay the panels off as though it is an incentive.

Here is my honest opinion. You chose to add the solar panels and you chose to finance them. Paying that off is not a selling point, it is just settling your own debt. Same with a financed HVAC system, a financed roof, or a pool you financed.

And a buyer who says they love the house enough to assume those payments? That is not the plan. That is luck. Do not build your pricing strategy around it.

Worth noting that this is Charleston, South Carolina, and solar may be far more common there than it is around Henry County. But the principle holds either way.

An agent offering to buy is not automatically shady

This is where I probably disagree with most of the comments she got. An agent offering to buy your house is not that uncommon, and it is not automatically a scam.

I have done it once. I went to the sellers completely straightforward and said here is what I see, here is what this house needs, it is a flip and it needs all of these things, and I would like to buy it at this price. And then I told them plainly that if they thought that price was too low, I would put it on the market for them or find them investors instead. No pressure either way. It worked out for everybody.

What makes it fine is transparency. What makes it a problem is an agent who quietly lets your listing sit, gives you no feedback, and then swoops in with a lowball number once you are exhausted.

Get your own appraisal before you answer

If your agent offers you a price and something about it feels off, do not argue about whether the number is fair. Go find out.

Pay for a private appraisal, or ask them to pay for one. Then you are negotiating against an independent professional’s number instead of against the opinion of the person on the other side of the deal. That one step removes almost all of the uncertainty.

My guess in this story is that he wanted it as a rental. Some agents do buy rentals, I do not, but it is not the craziest thing in the world.

There is a third option nobody mentioned

If your house needs real work and you do not want to do it, your agent should be able to bring you investors rather than buying it themselves.

That is something I do regularly. If you call me with a house that needs a lot, I have investors I work with and I will send them out to look at it. You get a cash offer, I stay on your side of the table, and nobody has to wonder whose interest is being served.

If your agent offers to buy your house

Do not say yes and do not say no. Do these three things first.

01

Get an independent number

A private appraisal costs a few hundred dollars and settles the entire question of whether the offer is fair. Cheapest peace of mind you will ever buy.

02

Ask what changes about representation

The moment they become the buyer, they stop being your advocate. Ask in writing who represents you from that point forward and what their brokerage requires.

03

Set a deadline and mean it

This seller gave hers a hard date to produce an offer or release her from the contract. She had a real offer at her number within days.

Questions worth asking out loud

Twenty eight showings with no offers is a pricing conversation, not a patience conversation. You can see how I price and report on a listing over on my sellers page.

What did the feedback from those showings actually say?
Who represents me if you become the buyer?
Will you support an independent appraisal before we talk numbers?
What happens if I want out of this listing agreement?

Not sure your listing is in good hands?

If your house has been sitting and the answers you are getting do not add up, let’s talk it through. No pressure and no sales pitch. McDonough, Locust Grove, Stockbridge, Hampton, and everywhere across Henry County.

Got a story you want me to react to next? Send it my way, or subscribe over on my YouTube channel. You can also reach me at 678-990-6133.

Megan Cox, REALTOR®, Move with Megan at The Legacy Real Estate Group, Georgia. This is general information and not legal advice. Please consult your broker or attorney for your specific situation. Equal Housing Opportunity.

Thinking About Your Next Move?

Whether you are buying, selling, or just curious what your home is worth, I would love to talk it through with you.

Schedule Your Free Call