
Reddit Reaction · For Sellers
Should You Panic After One Bad Showing?
October 5, 2026 · 4 min 28 sec · Megan Cox
One showing. Day one. The buyer said the walls did not match the price, and now she is ready to drop it. Here is why I would tell her to sit still.
What she posted
Our house hit the market today and the feedback we received already confirmed my fears. We sold our 1,500 square foot three bedroom to get more space and be closer to my husband’s job. Our realtor was confident it would sell quickly since it sits on two acres in a desirable area.
We replaced the flooring and did work on the front porch and back deck. Even with the updates, I was worried it would not show well. The walls have quite a few marks even after a deep cleaning, and both storm doors need replacing. We decided not to put any more money into it, and she assured us that if we priced it right it would sell fast.
We listed at 295,000. Today was our first showing and we have already gotten negative feedback. The client thinks the condition of the home, especially the walls, does not match the asking price. We have a lot of equity so we can drop the price if we need to. I was just hoping to close before we close on the house we are already under contract on.
Read the full transcript
Hey, sorry we missed a week, but we are back with a Reddit react. So this one is our house hit the market today, and the feedback we received already confirmed my fears.
“We recently decided to sell our 1,500 square foot three bedroom, two bath home and move to have a little more space, plus closer to my husband’s job. Our realtor was really confident that it would sell quickly due to the fact that it is on two acres in a very desirable area. We replaced the flooring throughout, which was much needed. We also did some work on the front porch and back deck.”
“Even with all the updates, the land and location, I’m still concerned that it wouldn’t look the best for potential buyers. The walls have quite a few marks, even after a deep cleaning, and the front and back storm doors both need to be replaced. After talking with our agent, we decided it would be best to not put any more money into updating it. And she assured us if we priced it right, it would sell quickly.”
“We listed it at 295,000 after she talked things over with her colleague. She said she was really confident going into the weekend and thought that maybe we’d even have an offer before the weekend was over. Well, today bright and early was our first showing and we have already gotten negative feedback. The client thinks the condition of the home, especially the walls, don’t match the asking price.”
“Our realtor did say that we would find out soon enough whether the price was right, but she had us thinking that we were already priced right. She’s been very open and honest to us about whether the asking price was fair on the house we’ve looked at buying. We have quite a bit of equity in this house, so it’s not like we’re trying to price higher. Just make sure we make a profit. If we need to drop the price, we can.”
“I just was excited about the possibility of being able to close prior to closing on the house we were under contract on. We can figure out a way to afford two mortgages temporarily if we have to, but of course, it would be great if we didn’t have to do that and we could avoid it altogether.”
Okay, so this one, there’s a lot to it. I think you’ve just got a really nervous seller. I’m sure the agent’s doing a good job at communicating, but that’s really important in all transactions with real estate, but especially in this market right now is communication with the seller.
Before, during like COVID times, you would list the house and it would be like almost instantly. Like I remember listing a house during COVID and within like 10 minutes of it hitting the MLS, we already had showings, like three or four showings. Like it was crazy. That’s not happening now. Even if you have a desirable house, it’s not happening that fast. Things are just slower. The economy. We all know life is expensive. So we aren’t getting buyers that fast.
So I think starting off, I’m not saying the agent did wrong or anything like that, but probably got the sellers’ hopes up like, “Oh, we got it priced right, probably this weekend.” I don’t think I would say that to anyone right now currently in this market, to say like, “Oh, it’ll probably be gone this weekend.” Because we really just don’t know for certain with everything going on.
But it was only one showing. And so that’s the biggest thing that I take from this is yes, it only takes one. Like you have one house, you only get one buyer. All of that is true, but don’t get yourself so beat up.
That’s why I have like a love hate relationship with the feedback. Like some agents don’t give feedback at all. Some do, some don’t. I can’t decide which side of that I’m on, if I think that it’s helpful or it’s hurtful. Because if you say not interested, that’s fine. Like you’re not interested, but you tell the seller that and they’re like, “But why? What’s wrong with it?” And I get it. This is like your prized possession. This is your home and you’re allowing people in. You’re allowing people to tour it. So I get it. It’s a vulnerable thing.
But sometimes the feedback hurts more than it helps, because now this person is like, “Oh, we can drop the price. We can do this. We can do that.” Hopefully they have a good agent who can talk them down and help them. But some agents, if you get an agent who is just looking to make a dollar, they’re going to be like, “Heck yeah.” Lower the price and you’re going to give a lot of equity away. So it really just matters on the agent.
But be patient. A lot of times we’ll have conversations where, let’s say I come in and I say, “Okay, I think your home’s worth 250.” And you’re like, “Can always come down, you can’t go up. Let’s start at 275.” If we agree on this and we set a list price of 275, if the feedback comes in that we’re overpriced, probably it’s because the agent’s doing the job that I was doing and running comps. So yes, you probably are overpriced.
But if your agent is telling you right now, like agents are very honest, and if they feel it’s high, we’re going to tell you it’s high. But if your agent’s telling you, “I think we’re priced right,” just be a little patient. If you have the time, just be patient. The right buyer will come.
And I know this market is not easy, and it’s definitely not fun right now, but just be patient. And if you can, if time allows, if you can afford your mortgage a little bit longer and things are okay, be patient and the right buyer will come and everything’s going to work out. So that’s my review for the week.
One showing is not a verdict
This is the biggest thing I take from the whole post. It was one showing. On day one.
Yes, it only takes one buyer. You have one house and you only need one person to say yes, and that is all true. But do not let a single comment beat you up before the first weekend is even over.
Buyers also tend to list every little thing they noticed, because that is exactly what the feedback form asks them to do. Marks on the walls and a couple of storm doors read brutal in writing. Most buyers walk past both without blinking.
I have a love hate thing with feedback
Some agents give feedback, some do not, and honestly I go back and forth on which side I am on.
If a buyer says not interested, fine, they are not interested. But then I have to tell the seller that, and the seller says but why, what is wrong with it? And I get it. This is your prized possession. You are letting strangers walk through your home. That is a vulnerable thing.
Sometimes feedback hurts more than it helps, because now you are sitting there thinking we can drop the price, we can do this, we can do that, after one person walked through.
This is where your agent matters
Hopefully you have an agent who can talk you off the ledge and help you think it through.
But if you have an agent who is just looking to make a dollar, they are going to hear that feedback and say heck yeah, lower the price. And you are going to give away a lot of equity for no reason, on day one, because of one opinion.
That is the real risk in this story. Not the walls.
If you priced above my number, expect this
Here is a conversation I have all the time. I come in and say I think your home is worth 250. You say we can always come down but we cannot go up, let’s start at 275. We agree and list at 275.
If feedback comes back saying overpriced, that is probably because the other agent ran the same comps I ran. So yes, you probably are a little high.
But if your agent is telling you that you are priced right, trust that. Agents are honest about this. If I think your number is too high, I am going to tell you it is too high.
This is not the COVID market anymore
I remember listing a house during COVID and within ten minutes of it hitting the MLS we already had three or four showings. It was crazy. That is not happening now.
Even a desirable house is not moving that fast. Things are slower, the economy is what it is, and life is expensive. We are not getting buyers at that pace anymore.
So I would not tell a seller today that their house will probably be gone this weekend. I do not think that agent did anything wrong, but saying that got these sellers’ hopes way up, and now day one feels like a failure when it is completely normal.
For context, homes in Henry County averaged about 63 days on market in August, with roughly 6.7 months of supply. One quiet showing tells you nothing.
If you can be patient, be patient
I know this market is not easy and it is definitely not fun right now. But if time allows, and you can carry the mortgage a little longer without putting yourself in a bind, give it some room.
The right buyer will come. Touch up the paint since it is cheap and it came up, and let the house get in front of more than one person before you start cutting your price.
Before you drop your price
Rough feedback on day one is not a reason to move your number. Do these three things first.
01
Wait for a pattern
One comment is noise. Give it five to ten showings. If every single buyer mentions the same thing, now you have real information worth acting on.
02
Fix the cheap stuff first
If the walls keep coming up, that is a few hundred dollars and a weekend. Always try paint before you try a ten thousand dollar price cut.
03
Look at showings, not opinions
Plenty of showings and no offers usually means condition or photos. Barely any showings at all is the one that points to price.
Questions worth asking out loud
Day one feedback is a conversation, not a verdict. You can see how I price and report on a listing over on my sellers page.
If this one hit home
Thinking about listing this fall?
If you want a straight answer on what your house is actually worth right now, and a plan that does not involve panicking in week one, let’s talk. No pressure and no sales pitch. McDonough, Locust Grove, Stockbridge, Hampton, and everywhere across Henry County.
Got a story you want me to react to next? Send it my way, or subscribe over on my YouTube channel. You can also reach me at 678-990-6133.
Market figures reflect August 2026 FMLS data for Henry County. Megan Cox, REALTOR®, Move with Megan at The Legacy Real Estate Group, Georgia. This is general information and not legal advice. Please consult your broker or attorney for your specific situation. Equal Housing Opportunity.
